Drawbacks of dollar-cost averaging
Despite being a valuable strategy for a lot of different investors, it’s important to consider some of its downsides:
-
It could cause missed opportunities if the market rises continually since you would end up buying fewer shares compared to the number you would have purchased with a big sum before the prices increased.
-
It’s a method that works best for volatile assets. The DCA would protect you from the volatility, ensuring you keep investing through thick and thin.
-
Like any other investment strategy, dollar cost-averaging doesn’t guarantee profits. Depending on the market situation, especially with sudden and deeper changes, you might suffer some losses.
-
Likewise, DCA won’t protect you from constant declines. For this plan to work, the price of your asset must be rising overall, even if it dips occasionally.
-
It could be particularly good for index funds and similar assets, since they are somewhat predictable in trying to follow a market index. It will be far riskier for stocks, and eventually, you will have to check your portfolio at least once in a while.
-
It’s important to keep attention to trading fees that you might encounter because of regular investing. It might be worth checking that information beforehand with your brokerage company.
In summary, dollar-cost averaging may be a good method to mitigate your risks, but it can also mean that you may miss out on bigger returns.
Who should use dollar-cost averaging?
DCA can be a rewarding investing strategy for many types of investors, including:
-
Inexperienced ones. It’s hard enough to start a regular habit of investing, especially if you try to learn too many things at once in an attempt to time the market. That’s where dollar-cost averaging can help, making things more simple and straightforward.
-
Investors focused on the long term, particularly with retirement accounts. With DCA it’s easier to keep your eyes on the prize and not be tempted by market variations. Also, investments will be automatic and easier to manage.
-
Investors with limited capital to invest. For those who have less, it can be a way to start investing right away, rather than wait for a huge sum of money that might not be available in the near future.
-
Investors who are not interested in doing extensive market research. It can be stressful and frustrating trying to time the market. Some people enjoy that, but it’s not for everyone.
-
Investors who want to decrease their risk, even if that means losing the possibility of greater returns. DCA can be a predictable and steady way to invest, especially with index funds and similar securities.
Example of dollar-cost averaging
Like before, suppose you have $600 to invest. In this example, you could invest everything at once, or you could spread your resources over 6 months. Here’s how things could play out with dollar-cost averaging:
MONTH
|
INVESTMENT
|
SHARE PRICE
|
SHARES PURCHASED
|
1
|
$100
|
$5
|
20
|
2
|
$100
|
$4
|
25
|
3
|
$100
|
$2
|
50
|
4
|
$100
|
$4
|
25
|
5
|
$100
|
$5
|
20
|
6
|
$100
|
$4
|
25
|
—
|
Total: $600
|
—
|
Total shares purchased: 165
|
In that hypothetical scenario, you invested $100 each month and bought 165 shares at an average price of $3.63 each.
Now let’s see it without DCA:
MONTH
|
INVESTMENT
|
SHARE PRICE
|
SHARES PURCHASED
|
1
|
$600
|
$5
|
120
|
2
|
$0
|
$4
|
0
|
3
|
$0
|
$2
|
0
|
4
|
$0
|
$4
|
0
|
5
|
$0
|
$5
|
0
|
6
|
$0
|
$4
|
0
|
—
|
Total: $600
|
—
|
Total shares purchased: 120
|
As you see, if you had invested the whole sum at month 1, you would have bought only 120 shares at an average price of $5 each. That’s 45 fewer shares and an increase of $1.37 in the price of each share.
Of course, in a perfect world, you would have invested everything at month 3 and then you would have 300 shares for $2 each. But what are the chances of you correctly predicting that? How about every time? Even for experienced investors who do extensive research and check the market frequently, it’s a tough game to master.
That’s why dollar-cost averaging can give you some certainty and reliable gains without that additional stress. Just keep reinvesting regularly and eventually, the results will come.
Common mistakes to avoid when using DCA
As with every investment strategy, there are some common mistakes that you should avoid:
-
If you have a large sum to invest and a trusted asset with a good price, you might be better off investing everything all at once. This could vary, but depending on the asset, a big lump sum investment will perform better.
-
Since you’ll be investing regularly, don’t forget to check transaction fees and commissions. They could add up and eat a significant portion of your gains.
-
DCA assumes that ultimately the price of an asset will rise. It won’t protect you if the market consistently declines or if your chosen asset underperforms.
-
If you’re investing for the short term, DCA might not be for you.
-
If you enjoy researching the market and changing your portfolio accordingly, DCA also might not be for you.
-
As with many investing methods, a diversified portfolio is best when using DCA.
-
It’s crucial to actually invest at regular intervals to make sure you maximize the benefits of DCA. Even skipping only two or three months could make a difference in how the averages perform.
Summary
Dollar-cost averaging is a great proven investing strategy that could help both novice and experienced investors maintain a healthy habit of regular investments, without needing to constantly monitor the market’s ups and downs.
While there are some downsides to consider, it can be a powerful tool to grow your returns over longer periods of time, even if you don’t want to play the market timing game.
As with any investment strategy, consider carefully how DCA will fit into your macro investment goals, and how it could help you reach them faster, with less stress.
As always, count on FBS to keep you well informed and to help you with all your trading needs.